Let’s be honest — curiosity, confidence, and a little bit of fun all come into play when you’re sending in a pic to get rated. I’ve always found good dick raters on OnlyFans to be more than just entertaining; it takes wit, empathy, and a genuine flair for flirtation to make the experience both thrilling and respectful. Over the last year, I’ve explored dozens of creators who truly excel in this niche, and after some hot conversations (and yes, a few ratings of my own), I’ve rounded up my favorite performers who know exactly how to keep things sexy, honest, and fun. Here’s my hand-picked list of the top 10 OnlyFans girls who are taking dick ratings to the next level.
💦 Creator: Laura Love
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/laura.love
Laura Love brings a sensual, fiery energy that’s unmatched. Her dick ratings often feel like a sexy roast — but in the best way. She’s confident, imaginative, and delivers content with heart-pounding charisma that left me grinning and a little bit flushed.
Why Follow Laura Love?
- Funny, spicy, and creative content
- Always personalized to the user
- High-quality visuals and responses
💦 Creator: Kyra Kinks
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/kyrakinks
Kyra Kinks wins the award for sex-positive badassery. She’s edgy, confident, and gives each rating with a mix of sultry critiques and empowering comments. Her kink knowledge adds some extra spice and makes the interaction feel deeply personal, every single time.
Why Follow Kyra Kinks?
- Kink-friendly and open-minded
- Straight-talk mixed with flirtation
- Quick and customized feedback
💦 Creator: Martina Grace
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/martinagrace
Martina Grace delivers seductive confidence and playful honesty every time. Her ratings are detailed, fair, and always wrapped in cheeky compliments or constructive sass — and that’s what makes them feel so damn good. She balances arousal with humor effortlessly, which is why I keep going back for more.
Why Follow Martina Grace?
- Custom video response options
- Flirty yet honest vibes
- Strong community and fan interaction
💦 Creator: Riley Rae
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/rileyrpremium
Riley Rae has that sweet-girl-next-door energy with a naughty streak, and it’s the perfect combo. Her dick ratings come with just the right amount of encouragement, and even when she teases, it’s done with genuine charm. I felt totally seen — and turned on.
Why Follow Riley Rae?
- Warm, teasing, and approachable
- Regular content updates and fan messages
- Custom voice and video ratings available
💦 Creator: Scarlett Vee
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/scarlettv
Scarlett Vee turns every submission into a luxurious experience. There’s a seductive sophistication about her approach — it’s like she’s whispering sweet, dirty secrets with every message. She’s confident, kind, and 100% unfiltered when rating with detail and desire.
Why Follow Scarlett Vee?
- Elegant and erotic energy
- Delivers both text and dramatic video ratings
- Excellent for submissive tension and encouragement
💦 Creator: Lila Lush
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/lilalush
Lila Lush is bubbly, cheeky, and always brutally honest in the most entertaining way. Her dick ratings often come with a wink and giggle, making the entire experience amusing, sexy, and light-hearted. She gave me the kind of feedback that felt like a sexy roast session with your hot best friend.
Why Follow Lila Lush?
- Funny AF and confidence-boosting
- Creative ratings with costumes and themes
- Massively engaged with fans
💦 Creator: Naomi Banks
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/naomibanks
Naomi has been around the adult scene for a while, and it shows in the way she commands attention. Her voice alone could make you blush. Her dick ratings are filled with intense eye contact, sensual criticism, and a bit of that dominatrix edge that keeps things thrilling.
Why Follow Naomi Banks?
- Deeply sensual and voice-based content
- High production quality
- Mature and assertive tone
💦 Creator: Bella Bliss
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/bellabliss
With a name like Bella Bliss, you’d expect sweetness — but she’s got a naughty twist that’s hard to resist. Her ratings are soft-spoken but spicy, always layered in appreciation while being real. If you like a mix of gentle teasing and lowkey flattery, she nails it.
Why Follow Bella Bliss?
- Soft, sensual atmosphere
- Focus on encouraging and candid feedback
- Customizable tip-based rating options
💦 Creator: Gia Jay
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/giajay
Gia Jay oozes confidence and sass in all the right ways. She doesn’t mince words but still manages to make even a harsh critique feel sexy. When I sent in mine, her video response felt personal, sultry, and real — exactly what makes a top-tier dick rater stand out.
Why Follow Gia Jay?
- Blunt, bold, and always entertaining
- Video ratings with spicy visuals
- Perfect mix of flirty and fierce
💦 Creator: Zoey Knox
🔗 OnlyFans: https://onlyfans.com/zoeyknox
If you’re looking for rawness and real interaction, Zoey brings the heat. She doesn’t play into gimmicks — her dick ratings are straight-up fire, with reactions that are often over-the-top in the best possible way. She made me laugh, blush, and watch her rating again (and again).
Why Follow Zoey Knox?
- Funny, loud, and completely unfiltered
- Immersive video ratings with acting flair
- Highly responsive and full of personality
How Do OnlyFans Dick Ratings Work?
Most creators offer several options for dick ratings — from basic scores to elaborate, custom video content. After subscribing to their OnlyFans, you can usually tip or message them directly to request a rating. You’ll often be asked your name, details about yourself, and even your preferred type of feedback (funny, mean, sweet, etc.). It’s both a confidence game and a way to spice things up — with real feedback that helps you feel good, curious, or just a little devilish for daring to ask.